Ink: Amanda Sun

Really a gorgeous cover.  Gorgeous book design in so general.  If you don’t usually buy paper copies this is one you might consider getting because its just that pretty.

General Summary: Katie is moping because she’s forced to live with her aunt in Japan instead of her grandparents in Canada.  Yeah….we’ve seen this before.  Add in a mysterious boy that Katie just knows is hers who has some freaky superpowers you get a Twilight redux that’s mildly interesting because Japan.

Review:

Okay.  This one.  I was really excited about it.  So much that I preordered that despite reading some dubious reviews from some trusted sources.

I should’ve relied on my friends.

I didn’t hate this one.  It had a nice idea that sort of succeeded and I think it captured Japanese culture pretty well.  Grant it, most of my exposure to Japanese culture has been limited to sushi, Hello Kitty, and Nancy Drew, and all those Karate Kid movies; but the book made me feel like I wasn’t in America.  And I liked that.  That part of the book really succeeded.

Oh, and who can forget this gem.  This was one of the movies I was forced to watch in my youth and unfortunately was one of my first impressions on Japan.  Yeah, it’s not exactly culturally enriching.  More like culturally offensive to both Japan and the US.  

The drawings in the book, though slightly random and sort of sparse (there were only like four of them and the book was like three hundred plus pages long) were pretty kick ass too.  That being said, this book had issues.

It was just a walking cliche.

That’s the best way to describe it.  That sounds horrible, but it’s true.  And yes, I know YA especially YA paranormal is a genre that is filled with cliches but come on Twilight came out almost ten years ago it’s time to move on.

It’s especially painful when your book has so many original elements like Ink does.  The Japanese mythology was refreshing.  I really feel like most of the genre is filled with Greek and or Judeo-Christian  mythology as bases for their various worlds and that’s a shame.  The world is filled with many different religions and mythologies and I think its about time that they’re incorporated in YA.  So plus to Sun for that..but at the same time the mythology at times felt a little weak.  I get that Sun didn’t want to info dump and I thank her for that but I wanted to know more.  And what I did see, I didn’t understand why it basically had to be used for a replacement for vampires.  Just ridiculous.

So how many Twilight cliches are in Ink?  Let’s count them shall we?

1) Our darling main character has a nontraditional family and is moving with a new relative in a far off land.

2) She has friends almost automatically and sees a boy with a bad reputation (which btw, am I the only one that finds it disturbing that she stalked a guy who she thought had a child on the way.  Really?  You think he’d want a new girlfriend when he has a kid on the way-priorites).

3)Bad boy turns her down but she keeps stalking even though he’s nasty.  She meanwhile suspects he’s not normal and turns to Google for help.

4) They unexpectedly get together usually when there’s bad weather and she confronts him.

5) He reveals his dark secret but since she’s “the one” she doesn’t freak out and says she can handle it.

6) A big bad usually comes at this point and fucks things up

7) Our damsel in distress meanwhile meets a new hot friend to set up a love triangle for the second book.

8) She then finds herself in peril that a sensible person could’ve avoided with pepper spray, taser gun, and/or a loud set of lungs and a good kick in the groin.

9) She has to be rescued

10) She ends in bittersweet misery because even though she and her love are safe darkness or scary redhead vampires surround them (i.e. there’s going to be a sequel).

That’s Ink minus the scary redheaded vampire.  It’s original enough.  It involves Japanese mythology and there’s no Cullen family, but it follows the Twilight formula which I find just to be lazy.  But then I read the rest of the book and it’s obvious she did research and I’m just….

Conflicted.

Though, according to  Nessa’s review some of  the Japanese elements weren’t even researched that much.  However, for the Japanese novice that I am I didn’t notice this much.

To be honest I probably would’ve given this one a solid six on my own review scale (three stars Good Reads) if it wouldn’t have ben for a certain fight that our main characters have.  Tomo you are an ass.  No means no and you need to respect that.  And Katie, you do NOT rationalize that he only did that just to protect you he was out of line regardless.

Yeah, I had to use  the mind bleach after those scenes.

Best Feature: Japan.  By far the best feature.  I actually felt like I was sucked into the country when reading this book.  Grant it, I don’t know squat about the country other than from my Nancy Drew games/books, but I really felt like I learned a lot from this book.  And not in the dorky educational type of way.

My first exposure to Japan and it’s my second favorite Nancy Drew and the Hardy Boys mystery next to Secrets of the Nile which is the best super mystery by far for obvious reasons (cough, Nancy and Frank, cough).

Worst Feature: Cliches.  Oh.  My.  God.  As I said before,  this book reminds me of a lot of other Twilight ripoffs I’ve read, but I like it slightly better because it involves Japan and the mythology is fairly unique.  But that being said, remember Carrier of the Mark?  If you don’t, I don’t blame you but it’s essentially that shitty Twilight wannabe book that took place in Ireland.  This reminded me of that book except it was better written and Sun didn’t go as far as to ripoff the Cullen family and its five thousand super powers.  The structure though and the main characters are a riff on the Stephenie Meyer series.  Honestly, I was able to tolerate a lot of these cliches.  It’s YA.  I almost think publishing companies require  cliches to be in the book , but in this book what would’ve been an awesome story is just overpowered by them.  And I really can’t help but feel sorry for it and it’s a book and books are in-animated objects that I shouldn’t feel sorry for.

Appropriateness: There are a few f bombs here, some violence (which includes dating violence).  It’s fairly typical to what you see in YA today though.

Blockbuster Worthy:  Maybe.  I need to read the second book.  Right now, I’m thinking no even though I’d love to see a movie that takes place in Japan.  The story is just too weak.

Overall Rating: Five out of ten bottles of ink.  I wanted to love this one, but I didn’t.  I couldn’t hate it either even though it relied on too many cliches and there were some groan worthy moments.  This book is a nice escape.  I think that’s the best way to describe it.  I actually felt like I was in Japan when reading it which is better than other designation reads I’ve read.  But considering I know next to nothing about Japan, that might not be saying much.

Advertisements

2 thoughts on “Ink: Amanda Sun

  1. Pingback: Why YA Authors Need to Watch K Drama:Gilded by Christina Farley | Howdy YAL!

  2. Pingback: Second Chances: Rain by Amanda Sun | Howdy YAL!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s