It’s been awhile since I’ve done a double review. So, yeah…double review time. Disclaimer: before I begin this thing, I have already read and reviewed the first four books of this series. To recap I started really liking this series and my feelings have sort of settled to meh by book four.
This series eerily reminds me of The Princess Diaries, which is a good and bad thing. Good at the beginning of the series, bad by the end. And to Meg Cabot’s series’ credit, I do think that by the end of the series, several of the issues I had with Mia were resolved. With Harriet…I hated her still by the end of the book series.
That being said, let’s dive into the double review so I can explain my grievances against Ms. Manners.
“My name is Harriet Manners, and I will always be a geek.”
The fifth book in the bestselling, award-winning GEEK GIRL series.
Harriet Manners knows almost every fact there is.
She knows duck-billed platypuses don’t have stomachs.
She knows that fourteen squirrels were once detained as spies.
She knows only one flag in the world features a building.
And for once, Harriet knows exactly how her life should go. She’s got it ALL planned out. So when love is in the air, Harriet is determined to Make Things Happen!
If only everyone else would stick to the script…
Has GEEK GIRL overstepped the mark, and is following the rules going to break hearts all over again?
This one was cringe worthy on so many levels. By this point, Harriet is suppose to have developed as a character somewhat. But she hasn’t. If anything, I feel like each of these books goes on a cyclic pattern of of character regression that seems to resolve itself by the end of the book. Only to reset itself by the beginning of the next installment.
Hell, I skimmed through the 400+ pages in less than 90 minutes and really didn’t miss much. Want the basic outline for one of these books , here you go:
- Harriet starts out with an annoying introduction of how perfect her life is (it’s not).
- Something happens that causes her to freak out and act like an ass-could be as simple as having a pimple or not getting a modeling job (because she’s an ass).
- Harriet overreacts
- This causes people to (rightfully) hate her.
- Somehow she gets hired for a modeling job when she really shouldn’t. Because God knows, girl is a liability.
- Exotic local photo shoot time!
- Obsession about boys/friends
- Time to make an ASS over self again.
- Harriet’s parental units act like asses because she had to pick it up from someone.
- At this point in the book, if this was a movie there’d be a sad montage.
- Somehow the problems are simply resolved with a couple of conversations.
- Harriet’s life is perfect again!
Seriously, that is your typical Geek Girl novel. This one was especially more squirm inducing than the rest with all that Team JINTH nonsense.
I was hoping by this time that Harriet would’ve matured a little bit. But she has not. Again, I think she’s regressed. I also wondered as I read this book if she’s on the spectrum. It really would make sense in a lot of ways. Especially if it was undiagnosed. But nope, Harriet is just an ass and nothing else which is a shame.
I wanted something to explain her actions, but other than her being an ass there’s nothing to explain her lack of social decorum or lack of empathy.
Besides, Harriet’s unrealistic actions. This book like the others is just ridiculous when it comes to modeling. Honestly, I feel like America’s Next Top Model does a better job portraying the industry and that’s saying something.
To be frank about it, had this not been the next to last installment of the series I probably would quit here. Just like a cameo-supporting character in this book I was ready to tell Harriet goodbye.
Overall Rating: A C-. I mean, it follows the formula to a T and that’s not exactly a good thing.
My name is Harriet Manners and I’ll be a geek forever…
Harriet Manners knows almost every fact there is.
Modelling isn’t a sure-fire route to popularity. Neither is making endless lists. The people you love don’t expect you to transform into someone else. Statistically, you are more likely to not meet your Australian ex-boyfriend in Australia than bump into him there.
So on the trip of a lifetime Down Under Harriet’s to-do lists are gone and it’s Nat’s time to shine! Yet with nearly-not-quite-boyfriend Jasper back home, Harriet’s completely unprepared to see supermodel ex Nick. Is the fashion world about to turn ugly for GEEK GIRL?
It’s time for Harriet to face the future. Time to work out where her heart lies. To learn how to let go…
Talk about Princess Diaries similarities, this book’s title is almost identical to the last book in the first series.
Pretty much what I said about the standard formula applies to this one but with two big differences. Smalle decides to throw a curveball with her audience and adds a serious dramatic plot point to this installment that is suppose to be a poignant moment from the series.
Spoiler alert: it’s not.
Instead, it felt oddly placed and I was like I’m really suppose to care for this character….Also, the character’s death was ridiculously fast. Especially considering that Harriet didn’t even know said character was ill and then once she knows she kicks the bucket within the span of a week.
So, the big death. Didn’t really make a difference to this book. The other thing that was different about this particular installment was the love triangle.
Going back to The Princess Diaries series…because I can’t help but think of that series when I read the Geek Girl books. PD had its own love triangle that was hit and miss with many fans. At the time I first read the book, I liked it and wanted Mia to jilt Michael because I was tired of Michael and knew it would be the unexpected choice. Looking back, that was kind of dumb but JP and Mia even made more sense than Jasper and Harriet and that’s saying something.
As far as Jasper is concerned, I really view him as being a background character that was randomly added to give Harriet more of a social life. I honestly found his attraction to her to be out of place. This is in contrast to the PD series where at least JP’s attraction to Mia is relatively explained.
TBH though, I find it hard to believe that anyone would be attracted to Harriet. She really is a horrible character. As I had mentioned she does not grow any at all throughout the books and her quirkiness is no longer cute. In fact, I really do believe that the character is on the spectrum and undiagnosed. It was really the only thing that kept me reading and from outright wanting to throttle her, but I digress.
At the end of the day, I was relieved when I closed Forever Geek. This is one series that sort of left me with a sour taste in my mouth. There was definitely potential with this series but rather than expanding upon said potential it was squandered and left a bit of a mess.
If you want a fun light hearted series, I’m not going to be recommending this one. Check out it’s obvious inspiration (The Princess Diaries) some of the middle books might be blah but at least Mia grows as a character. Harriet does not.
Overall Rating: A C