It feels like there’s no ground beneath me, like everything I’ve ever done has been a lie. Like I’m breaking apart, shattering. Who am I? Where do I belong?
Jasmine de los Santos has always done what’s expected of her. Pretty and popular, she’s studied hard, made her Filipino immigrant parents proud and is ready to reap the rewards in the form of a full college scholarship.
And then everything shatters. A national scholar award invitation compels her parents to reveal the truth: their visas expired years ago. Her entire family is illegal. That means no scholarships, maybe no college at all and the very real threat of deportation.
For the first time, Jasmine rebels, trying all those teen things she never had time for in the past. Even as she’s trying to make sense of her new world, it’s turned upside down by Royce Blakely, the charming son of a high-ranking congressman. Jasmine no longer has any idea where—or if—she fits into the American Dream. All she knows is that she’s not giving up. Because when the rules you lived by no longer apply, the only thing to do is make up your own.
I’ve outgrown Melissa de la Cruz’s books. It’s a sad fact. At some point I plan to reread the Blue Bloods books, but I feel like it is going to be a sea of disappointment and embarrassment that I ever liked her stuff. Still, she writes really good premises and I find myself ridiculously attracted to her blurbs. Like this one.
But still, it sat on my shelf for awhile. However, after the God awful month of executive orders that the Trump administration has thrown on us I have been wanting to read more issue relevant books.
And I did remember liking Melissa’s Fresh Off the Boat, I at least remember thinking that book had more heart to it than some of her frothier rich people novels-not that some of those can be okay, they just get very stale after awhile.
The thing is, that Something In Between didn’t have that realness quality about it, even though it dealt with some topics that were very near and dear to Melissa’s own personal life.
I got to say, the romance was cringe worthy and completely unrealistic. Jas and Royce fall ridiculously in love within a couple of pages of looks and text messages. It make Skyjack (Jack/Schuyler from Blue Bloods ) look more realistic and in hindsight that pairing was illy paced, but to its credit it was a paranormal romance. Here though, other than he’s handsome/she’s hot I didn’t get the attraction. Maybe because both of these characters came off as bland. Like Cinderella and Prince Charming Disney movie bland.
I often think it’s harder to write a contemporary than a paranormal or fantasy novel, because the characters are often the focus of the novel. Unless it’s bitchy blonde vampire socialites, I always think Melissa’s characters suffer from vapidness and this book was no exception to that. I honestly did not get how Jas won this big scholarship. She doesn’t come off as particularly smart or driven, and while she did do some cheerleading she didn’t really have the sort of resume that most Ivy bound kids have. Royce was even duller than Jas, I can’t even remember if he had a hobby outside of sending really embarrassing texts to his girlfriend and then getting his Paul Ryan Wannabe father go against his core conservative values.
And that had me roll my eyes and just seethe with anger. I am already not a huge fan of the Republican party-in fact, I’d say right now I have no tolerance for what they’re preaching at least before the tea party and the racist party of Trump, I could at least sort of get where they’re coming from in the Bush era but that’s besides the point. Here, seeing Royce’s asshole of a congressman make an exception for one family had me rolling my eyes.
And yes, I did vaguely recall reading about private bills very briefly in the Immigration Law course I took 2L year, but I also remember hearing that they hardly ever happen and other than being briefly mentioned we didn’t discuss them hardly any. Instead, we talked a lot about work visas and I find it difficult to believe that Jas’s working class family would even acquire a visa in the first place.
Unskilled workers have the burnt end of the deal immigration wise, and this book didn’t seem to even discuss that. Yes, I understand that Ms. de la Cruz is not a lawyer and that it’s possible in her own case that her family could’ve gotten in on such visas-but it doesn’t happen that often. Part of the reason why is in order to get a work visa the company has to show that there are no qualified American workers. Sort of hard to do with an unskilled job.
And then there was that farce of a court hearing…I’m not even going to talk about it.
And while I think there was some work into looking up the immigration process I don’t think it encompassed a lot of the issues on a whole of what is going on. About how broken the process is-and it’s even more fucked up now, for obvious reasons most involving a big fat Orange Boob.
Look, I can’t fault Ms. de la Cruz too much on the legalities. Immigration law itself is a beast, and there’s a lot of reasons why attorneys don’t practice it. And even very seasoned lawyers can’t figure out some of the nuances involving the process-and I’m quoting some lecturer on an online CLE I took a couple of weeks ago almost verbatim on that one.
I just don’t know, having this conservative congressman who is described as being an asshole towards immigrants for a big chunk of the book being Jas’s savior rubs me the wrong way. Why is it okay for her to have a private bill while the congressman roots for legislation to harm constant others in her position? I just didn’t like this congressman and wanted to go to a town hall to tell him what a hypocrite he was and that even though Jas situation was awful and she deserved help all the other undocumented immigrants in his district deserved to be treated like real people and not criminals. He doesn’t even have a come to Jesus moment in the book and realizes that his hardline stanch is that of an asshole.
But I digress..
If you can look past the hypocrisy and the cringe worthy romance, this one is readable. That is one thing I will always give de la Cruz, her stuff is readable. But God there’s so much cringe and hypocrisy that I did close it a couple of times throughout reading it just to rant. The immigration stuff while researched (enough) isn’t fully researched in some aspects.
The parts that rang truest about the book were the brief insights we got into Filipino culture, but those for the most part were very brief.
Overall Rating: A C