A cappella just got a makeover.
Jordan Sun is embarking on her junior year at the Kensington-Blaine Boarding School for the Performing Arts, hopeful that this will be her time: the year she finally gets cast in the school musical. But when her low Alto 2 voice gets her shut out for the third straight year—threatening her future at Kensington-Blaine and jeopardizing her college applications—she’s forced to consider nontraditional options.
In Jordan’s case, really nontraditional. A spot has opened up in the Sharpshooters, Kensington’s elite a cappella octet. Worshipped…revered…all male. Desperate to prove herself, Jordan auditions in her most convincing drag, and it turns out that Jordan Sun, Tenor 1, is exactly what the Sharps are looking for.
Jordan finds herself enmeshed in a precarious juggling act: making friends, alienating friends, crushing on a guy, crushing on a girl, and navigating decades-old rivalries. With her secret growing heavier every day, Jordan pushes beyond gender norms to confront what it means to be a girl (and a guy) in a male-dominated society, and—most importantly—what it means to be herself.
Good news guys, I finished my reading goal for 2017. Fifty books. Grant it, I did DNF a few of them but I still technically read fifty books.
Anyway, Noteworthy was the book that pushed me over the top. I had mixed feelings about this book. Overall, I’m giving it a sold B rating but there were some things that didn’t work for me.
What worked. The setting. From what I could tell it was pretty spot on. My sister went to a performing arts boarding school, and it was pretty much like Kensington-Blaine (grant it, her focus was in playing the oboe, not singing or theater, but still same sort of deal). I also really liked the way that Redgate explored how economically disadvantaged kids fare at such schools.
To be blunt about it, my sister experienced hell when she was at her fancy pants performing arts high school mainly becuase she was a scholarship student. Grant it, my family was pretty solid middle class-my parents own their home and we never were on any benefits like Jordan and her family-but without a scholarship there would’ve been no way that she could’ve gone to that school and it was the first time she really had to deal with classism.
My mom actually had more of a home life like Jordan-her dad was in a wheelchair and even though her parents worked they survived in part because of Social Security and ate pretty much a staple diet of dried beans for a lot of her childhood. Reading Jordan’s narrative, reminded me of a lot of the issues my mom described that she faced growing up, so those two parts of the book were very relatable to me even though I had not directly experienced either of them.
So those two parts of the book-the handling of the setting and poverty were at least really well done from what I have experienced. I also loved how diverse this book is. There are a variety of different character from different backgrounds and the boarding school really leads to a great setting for them to interact.
Jordan was also an entertaining narrator and sort of atypical. She is actually one of the few YA character who gender bends who I think realistically could pull it off-at least from a physical perspective.
She’s actually described as looking androgynous, which I know shocking as this may sound doesn’t happen a lot with this trope.
The gender bend storyline didn’t drive me that crazy either. I did think before reading it, that Jordan would question her gender identity, but really that’s not a factor in this book. I am glad that some discussion was made about the difference between cross dressing and being transgender.
The relationships between the singing group were also nice. The dynamics make it perfectly acceptable for a companion sequel-just saying-and I felt like there was a lot to explore here.
The romance also didn’t bother me, though I don’t really know if it was needed. I was satisfied enough with the character development for Jordan and the platonic relationships she developed with the rest of the team.
What didn’t work?
Oh, the pacing.
It dragged so freaking much in parts. I felt like if the book could’ve cut down a little bit of the page count it would’ve been better off for it.
Also, the sheet ludicrousness of Jordan’s gender bending experience made me roll my eyes. You would’ve thought that the faculty sponsor would’ve at least looked to see if Julian existed for the pure purpose of checking his eligibility to see if whether or not his grades allowed him to compete in the group.
Stephenie Meyer excuse, it’s fiction.
Still, it’s hard to let something like that go when you’re reading, especially if you are the super neurotic reader like yours truly.
Overall, I do recommend Noteworthy. It does have some really good bits to it, but there were some issues. If you can handle the slowish pacing and can suspend logic then you might should give this one a try.
Overall Rating: A solid B.