Talking to other people isn’t Kate Bailey’s favorite activity. She’d much rather be out on the lake, soaking up the solitude and sunshine. So when her best friend, Alana, convinces Kate to join their high school’s podcast, Kate is not expecting to be chosen as the host. Now she’ll have to answer calls and give advice on the air? Impossible.
But to Kate’s surprise, she turns out to be pretty good at the hosting gig. Then the podcast gets in a call from an anonymous guy, asking for advice about his unnamed crush. Kate is pretty sure that the caller is gorgeous Diego Martinez, and even surer that the girl in question is Alana. Kate is excited for her friend … until Kate herself starts to develop feelings for Diego. Suddenly, Kate finds that while doling out wisdom to others may be easy, asking for help is tougher than it looks, and following your own advice is even harder.
Kasie West’s adorable story of secrets, love, and friendship is sure to win over hearts everywhere.
Kasie West is the 2010’s version of Meg Cabot. That is both a good and bad thing. Like Cabot, she write cute, fluffy books that give you the feels and she’s extremely prolific. Also, like Cabot, sometimes the quality suffers as a result of the prolificness.
Listen to Your Heart feels very phoned in, which is kind of ironic because it’s about a girl who who has a podcast show where people call in to ask for advice.
The concept of the story itself isn’t that original. There are lots of stories that share the sort of plot line that this story has. I probably watched a couple of Hallmark movies with similar plots. What would make this concept good, is the execution. Are the characters fully fleshed out? Is the chemistry with the characters palatable? Is there some sort of plot twist that makes the story original despite having what appears to be a fairly generic concept/plot?
All the answer to these questions is no with this book. It was as if West was clearly phoning this one in. The MC lives near the lake that’s her defining characterization. And she has lots of cousins. One whose four. This is pointed out every time, Cora-the four year-old, makes an appearance. The only reason I remember Cora is it’s made pretty fucking clear through the book that she’s four-years-old.
There’s lots of other cousin’s too. Most of them are as blah as wallpaper. The only one besides Cora I remember is Liz or it Liza, whoever she is she’s the one who randomly goes to a tutoring center so that Kate can interact with Diego.
Diego is the love interest, BTW. Though, Kate doesn’t really have feelings or decent interaction with him for most of the book. Hell, I thought her love interest was going to be someone else who she at least sort of shared chemistry with. But apparently, I was wrong.
Me missing ships does happen occasionally. See the Harry Potter books where I was not able to guess the horrid cannon couples we got-Heron is totally going to go to wizard divorce court you know it and I know it and I won’t even get started on my hatred for the shallow ship that is Hinny (it should’ve been Harmony, damn it, even Rowling knows it and now admits it).
If you made it past my Harry Potter ship rant (it really doesn’t take much to get me started) you’ll see that I really didn’t get the Diego/Kate relationship because other than a couple of interactions with the two of them, there isn’t that much interaction with the two of them.
The story itself was vanilla. I was hoping for a couple of more plot twists than we got. I really felt this could’ve been developed more than it was. Even the podcast itself was boring, nothing really developed from it and I kind of was surprise that a high school teacher would actually okay an advice podcast for high school kids. Then again, what do I know…
After reading this, a part of me felt cynical. Contemporary YA is usually my jam. Yes, it can be cheesy and unrealistic, but that’s part of what I love about it. With this book I just felt complete blah-ness there was nothing that had me loving the characters or interested in the story. I knew what was going to happen. Even worse, the only thing that really was unexpected was the ship. And it wasn’t because the ship itself was unsuspected. Rather, it was how banal and chemistry-less the ship was. Hell, I thought the interaction between the MC and her archenemy was better than her interaction with Diego.
If you are a die hard Kasie West fan you’ll probably read this one and moderately enjoy it. I’ll admit that during the days Meg Cabot was uber prolific I read every book by her even if it was not so good and told myself it was good. I could see West fans doing that too. However, the book is not going to sit on you later on when you look at West’s backlist. Much like when I think of Meg Cabot’s books I do usually not think about How to be Popular (which I think is one of Cabot’s worse).
Would I say it’s the worst book ever? Hardly. But it’s not worth its space on my shelves and for someone who gets as much praise as West does, it was a bit of a fail.
Overall Rating: An F.